Erica Case: Artistic Director
she/her

Erica Case is a Milwaukee native with over 10 years of local theater experience. She was an owner and founder of The Alchemist Theatre & Lounge, and is currently serving on the Board of Schmitz n’ Giggles. Erica has worked as a director, designer, performer and more. Erica has a passion for innovative perspectives to classic works and for pushing creative boundaries.

Alex Scheurell: Executive Director
he/him

Alex is one of the three founding members of All In Productions, and has served in an executive role with the company since its founding. Production staff credits with AIP include THE LAST FIVE YEARS, SHAPE OF THINGS, LITTLE SHOP OF HORRORS, DOGFIGHT, WILD PARTY, CONSTELLATIONS, and HEDWIG AND THE ANGRY INCH. A graduate of the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Alex has also appeared as both an actor and worked on production staff dozens of productions in Milwaukee. Favorites include RENT and LES MISERABLES with GCT, COWBOY VERSUS SAMURAI with Lotus Theatre, and RETRO COMEDY NIGHT with Milwaukee Comedy.

He resides in Bayside with his wife, Katie and their very opinionated cat, Pip. When not engaged in various theatrical projects, Alex enjoys gradually working his way through his video and tabletop game backlog, doing chaotic things in D&D, running, cooking, and trying to not get too annoyed at the Packers.

Grace “Gray” Berendt: Company Member
they/them

Gray Berendt is a Milwaukee based actor and artist, born and raised, who received their BFA in Acting from the University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee. Since then, they have been involved in a number of productions throughout the greater Milwaukee area. Some of their favorite roles include Ferdinand, Antonio, Ariel 1, and Trinculo in Voices Found Repertory Theatre’s five-person production of “The Tempest”, Charlotte/Mary in Next Act Theatre’s staged reading of “Mrs. Christie”, Mash in “Stupid F*cking Bird” performed at Sunstone Studios MKE by Placeholder Players, Exeter and Nym in Wisconsin Classic Stage’s “Henry V”, and Ophelia in Theatre Nervosa’s production of “Hamlet & Ophelia”. In addition to their acting endeavors, they were recently on Wardrobe Crew for several of the Milwaukee Repertory Theatre’s productions in 2024 and 2025.

Gray is excited to be supporting All In Productions in their efforts to create and explore stories that capture new and underrepresented perspectives. Outside of theatre, Gray enjoys many other forms of art such as drawing, sculpture, video editing, and writing. They look forward to forging new connections among the Milwaukee theatre community!

Heather David: Company Member
she/they

Heather has enjoyed performing on stages from Buffalo to Boston in musicals, plays, and even a cappella concerts! She carries 10+ years of musical know-how and can still play a mean oboe if the occasion arises. She hopes to bring about positive and powerful change in the Milwaukee theatre area, making the entire experience accessible (and fun!) for all.

Previous favorite roles have been Brooke Wyndham in Legally Blonde (WCT), Mimi in RENT (WCT), Nellie Forbush in South Pacific, Minnie Fay in Hello Dolly, and most recently Veronica in Cowboy Versus Samurai (Lotus).

Outside of the limelight Heather enjoys video games, D&D, and keeping all of the tiny things in her house alive (two cats, child, garden). GO BILLS

Christopher Goode: Company Member
he/him

Christopher is a Milwaukee-based actor, director, improviser, and occasional sketch comedy writer. Over the past few years you could have found him acting with Windfall Theatre, doing improv and sketch comedy at Interchange Theatre, performing experimental musical performance pieces with his partner Mia at the Milwaukee Fringe Festival, and doing all of the above with Schmitz n’ Giggles.

Some of his favorite hobbies include yoga, gaming, playing with his dog Rosco, and watching The Sopranos. He’ll do his Tony impression for you if you ask. Also if you don’t.

Amanda J. Hull: Company Member
she/her

Amanda is a graduate of UW-Milwaukee’s BFA Acting and Musical Theatre Programs and a local Director, Actor/Singer and theatre professional. She is Costume Designer/Prop Master/One Act Director for Shorewood Drama, Director of St. Robert School Musical & the Shorewood Drama Jr. Summer Musical. She often enjoys working with Milwaukee Irish Arts as a Director, Actor or Costumer. Her acting credits include many local theatres but most frequently she has performed with Windfall Theatre. She served as Associate Producer/Production Manager/Aesthetic Designer for the former Milwaukee Entertainment Group, Production Manager/Costume Designer for Cabaret Milwaukee, Costume Designer at South Milwaukee HS and a voting member of The Milwaukee Theatre Alliance.

She and her husband Cole own The Brick House Mke. an intimate arts and event venue in Riverwest. They have two adorable kiddos, Dillon who is two and Beckett who is new! And a head strong and equally adorable dog, Tito, who is five. They enjoy singing, walks, food with friends, reading, planting flowers and having adventures together.

Ekene Ikegwuani: Company Member
they/them

Ekene is an artist from the Twin Cities, Minnesota, now based in Milwaukee. They are primarily focused on telling stories in a variety forms, whether that is on stage, on the screen, or on a beat. A company member of the Constructivists, people may have seen them perform or heard their work at many Constructivists performances over the past few years, including WINK, BABEL, THE TOTALITARIANS, I’M GONNA PRAY FOR YOU SO HARD, IN THE CANYON, and THE BEAUTY QUEEN OF LEENANE. When not doing theatre, Ekene can be found organizing with the Milwaukee Anti-War Committee, watching movies with their fiancée, playing video games, reading, or working on their debut EP.

Dennis Lewis: Company Member
he/him

Dennis is a Milwaukee-born singer, actor and model. He has most recently had the opportunity to perform as a cast member in RENT at Outskirts Theater, SISTER ACT at Skylight Music Theater and THE AGITATORS at Acacia Theatre. When not on stage he can be found teaching and training the Brazilian martial art Capoeira or serving his community as a Fire Lieutenant on the Milwaukee Fire Department.

Martilia Marechal: Company Member
she/her

Martilia was born and raised in Milwaukee, and attended Marquette University where she received her BA in Theatre Arts and Psychology. While in college, Martilia mainly enjoyed performing, however, she also learned to sound design, which is what she’s mainly doing in the theatre scene currently. Since graduating in 2023, Martilia has had the opportunity to associate sound design shows with Next Act Theatre, Milwaukee Chamber Theatre, and Milwaukee Rep. In addition, she’s had the pleasure of sound designing for THE BEAUTY QUEEN OF LEENANE! and IN THE CANYON at The Constructivists, EVERY BRILLIANT THING at Milwaukee Chamber Theatre, JEEVES SAVES THE DAY at Third Avenue Playworks, and HIP HOP HOORAY with Black Arts MKE. When she’s not actively working on a production, she also has a day job working with children in a behavioral therapy clinic.

Though Martilia’s schedule is pretty busy, when she has downtime she enjoys making art/crafting, dogsitting, trying new recipes, playing her Nintendo Switch, and going to trivia nights at the County Clare. She is very excited to be joining the AIP team and assist in creating beautiful projects!

Shayne Patrick: Company Member
he/him

Shayne Patrick is an Indigenous actor, musician, and writer based in Milwaukee, and a proud member of the Red Cliff Band of Lake Superior Chippewa. A graduate of UW–Green Bay and former acting intern with Milwaukee Repertory Theater, Shayne has performed with a diverse array of theatre companies across Wisconsin and is passionate about community-rooted storytelling.

Recent performance highlights include All Is Calm (Vanguard Productions), Hypotheticals (Kith & Kin), RIP – A Musical Comedy of Life and Death, and the podcasts Vigil and Psychopompos. He is also the lead vocalist and co-songwriter for the local band Sorry, We’re Open, and a teaching artist with First Stage, where he shares his passion for storytelling with the next generation. Shayne is honored to support bold, inclusive theatre through his work with All In Productions. He is grateful for the enduring support of his family, friends, and Selena.

Justin Spanbauer: Company Member
he/him

Justin is a father first and a Milwaukee area theatre collaborator second. He has shared his talents as an actor, director, playwright and sound designer at his alma mater UW-Stevens Point as well as various community theatres across the greater Milwaukee area.

Eugene James Strei: Company Member
he/him

Eugene James Strei is an actor and playwright based in Milwaukee, WI. He received his BFA in musical theatre and a minor in dance from the University of Wisconsin – Milwaukee. Since graduating, Eugene has had the pleasure of working with Theatrical Tendencies, Forte Theatre, Pink Umbrella Theatre Company and Skylight Music Theatre. As a playwright, his work has been performed on stages in Wisconsin and California. Eugene’s play “Hold Him Down” is being published as part of the “We/Us Anthology”, a collection of short plays by and for the trans community. Through his writing and acting, Eugene hopes to continue telling stories of trans joy onstage.

When not on stage, Eugene somehow finds the time to explore local parks and play with his cat, Cowboy.